AS
Good, but could be better for this money
I bought this amp for my Yamaha NS-10M Studio monitors using it with my Apollo Twin MKII audio interface. Today CLA-10 monitors are considered by most as the best replica of NS-10's, and CLA-200 amp is designed especially for CLA-10's. So I thought this amp would be the best match for my NS-10's.
Now that I've bought the amp and used it a few days, I can't tell that CLA-200 is ideal for NS-10's, but nevertheless, it's really a good option and I don't regret buying it. For people looking for the ideal match, I would recommend considering old used vintage amps – it might be hard to find the right one in good conditions on the secondary market, and the price usually is much higher than CLA-200's + some additional risks, but it can be worth it. Personally, I'm pretty fine with CLA-200.
Pros:
+ Sounds and looks really great
+ Silent (even my laptop is much louder)
+ Has Link outputs (I use them for a subwoofer even though it also has its link outputs, just love how all the system works this way)
+ It's heavy, but you only need 4 rack screws in the front to mount it. I thought I'd need some extra mounting using its back "ears".
Cons:
- VU meters don't work well with NS-10, they were designed for CLA-10's, and probably due to some difference in the circuit, you'd hardly see any movements on VU meters. It's a known issue.
- At the minimum volume knob positions (1-1) the real volume differs between two speakers. The problem eliminates from the second volume knob positions (2-2, 3-3 and higher). It might seem not critical (and it's really not that much), but in pair with my Apollo Twin, I don't need that much amplification as I usually work on low volumes.
- When I received my CLA-200, there was a strange sound from the inside when moving the amp. When I uncovered it, it had turned out that one of the screws was unscrewed. I fixed the problem but it was an unpleasant moment.
Would be nice to have:
~ XLR speaker outputs
~ VU meters mode switch for NS-10's
Now that I've bought the amp and used it a few days, I can't tell that CLA-200 is ideal for NS-10's, but nevertheless, it's really a good option and I don't regret buying it. For people looking for the ideal match, I would recommend considering old used vintage amps – it might be hard to find the right one in good conditions on the secondary market, and the price usually is much higher than CLA-200's + some additional risks, but it can be worth it. Personally, I'm pretty fine with CLA-200.
Pros:
+ Sounds and looks really great
+ Silent (even my laptop is much louder)
+ Has Link outputs (I use them for a subwoofer even though it also has its link outputs, just love how all the system works this way)
+ It's heavy, but you only need 4 rack screws in the front to mount it. I thought I'd need some extra mounting using its back "ears".
Cons:
- VU meters don't work well with NS-10, they were designed for CLA-10's, and probably due to some difference in the circuit, you'd hardly see any movements on VU meters. It's a known issue.
- At the minimum volume knob positions (1-1) the real volume differs between two speakers. The problem eliminates from the second volume knob positions (2-2, 3-3 and higher). It might seem not critical (and it's really not that much), but in pair with my Apollo Twin, I don't need that much amplification as I usually work on low volumes.
- When I received my CLA-200, there was a strange sound from the inside when moving the amp. When I uncovered it, it had turned out that one of the screws was unscrewed. I fixed the problem but it was an unpleasant moment.
Would be nice to have:
~ XLR speaker outputs
~ VU meters mode switch for NS-10's
10
3
Report
W
all 3 different units had faults
I've bought this amp before and returned it due to faults twice, now I decided to try it again to see if the problems are fixed and I needed a new amp due to an old one dying.
The first time (22.09.2023) the transformer was loose and I noticed that the meters didn't move at all. I have multiple vintage amps with VU meters, they have all been calibrated to be as accurate as possible. I used these to test the amp. The CLA-200 has to send out over 15 watts of power before the VU meters start moving a little, when they claim to send out about 2 watts you could be pumping over 100 watts into your speakers. To me it feels like they put -20dB meters in it and just labeled them wrong. This is a dangerous thing since this could've caused serious damage to vintage speakers. In terms of features it's a very simple power amp it doesn't really have anything special to offer except for the VU meters (that don't work correctly.) At first I just thought I had received a broken unit, so I sent it back and got a new one.
The second (18.10.2023) unit had severely bent rear mounting brackets and yet again the meters did not move much. It also had a volume difference between the channels even at higher volumes, it is a common complaint with lower volumes on this amp. I sent it back and got my money back. I did however put in a complaint with Avantone, they would reply and ask me to send proof and provide more detail. Whenever I did this (tried 4 times) they would just not reply back.
This amp does sound very good which is my reason for trying again. I've always had bad luck with expensive products so figured why not.
The issue this time is that when I opened the box and took the unit out I heard a rattle. One of the screws holding the amplification board onto the cooling had come completely loose, I could see that 3 other screw were backing themselves out as well. For some reason yesterday when I turned the amp on it tripped a breaker, I was using about 400 watts total on this breaker. It has not happened since but I found it very odd.
I'm thinking about just putting custom meters in it because I would like it to work like it should. I will reach out to Avantone with this review and see if they will finally reply.
So in short, I think this amp sounds very good but the build quality is the worst I've seen in any product I've ever owned. And the main attraction doesn't work the way it should. And Avantone support is not there when you need it.
The first time (22.09.2023) the transformer was loose and I noticed that the meters didn't move at all. I have multiple vintage amps with VU meters, they have all been calibrated to be as accurate as possible. I used these to test the amp. The CLA-200 has to send out over 15 watts of power before the VU meters start moving a little, when they claim to send out about 2 watts you could be pumping over 100 watts into your speakers. To me it feels like they put -20dB meters in it and just labeled them wrong. This is a dangerous thing since this could've caused serious damage to vintage speakers. In terms of features it's a very simple power amp it doesn't really have anything special to offer except for the VU meters (that don't work correctly.) At first I just thought I had received a broken unit, so I sent it back and got a new one.
The second (18.10.2023) unit had severely bent rear mounting brackets and yet again the meters did not move much. It also had a volume difference between the channels even at higher volumes, it is a common complaint with lower volumes on this amp. I sent it back and got my money back. I did however put in a complaint with Avantone, they would reply and ask me to send proof and provide more detail. Whenever I did this (tried 4 times) they would just not reply back.
This amp does sound very good which is my reason for trying again. I've always had bad luck with expensive products so figured why not.
The issue this time is that when I opened the box and took the unit out I heard a rattle. One of the screws holding the amplification board onto the cooling had come completely loose, I could see that 3 other screw were backing themselves out as well. For some reason yesterday when I turned the amp on it tripped a breaker, I was using about 400 watts total on this breaker. It has not happened since but I found it very odd.
I'm thinking about just putting custom meters in it because I would like it to work like it should. I will reach out to Avantone with this review and see if they will finally reply.
So in short, I think this amp sounds very good but the build quality is the worst I've seen in any product I've ever owned. And the main attraction doesn't work the way it should. And Avantone support is not there when you need it.
0
0
Report